Metronet Information Literacy Initiative

 

Evaluate Using ART

Page history last edited by Karen 1 yr ago

Creating a research project assignment which teaches information literacy skills is a work of ART;

you need a good research project in order to teach the research process

A: Is it Authentic?

  • Are the students asked to answer real questions?
  • Does the assignment offer choices?  Are the topics of choice relevant to students' lives?
  • Does the project encourage students to . . . Think critically?  Solve problems?  Be creative?
  • Can the final product be shared with a real audience in the school, community, or world? 

R: Does it facilitate the Research Process?

How are the students guided to . . .

  • Develop and refine a question or hypothesis for their project?
  • Locate, gather, and evaluate information from a variety of reliable resources?
  • Record, summarize, and cite the information which they find and use?
  • Reflect upon what they are learning in order to make a conclusion?
  • Develop communication skills, whether in a written, oral, or other format?
  • Evaluate what they are doing throughout the project as well as at the end?

How does the assignment . . .

  • Encourage students to reflect upon, revisit, revise, and improve their projects?
  • Encourage students to use the school media center or another type of library?
  • Encourage and facilitate the responsible use of technology?
  • Help students develop a collaborative research community?
  • Help students avoid plagiarism and create original work?

T: Is it well-supported by the Teacher?

Do the assignment's instructions . . .

  • State goals for what the students should learn about the research process?
  • Describe and set expectations regarding the elements of a quality research process? 
  • Emphasize the research process by having parts of the process due at intervals?

Does the teacher . . .

  • Give examples of (or model) what quality research looks like? 
  • Give tools to help students through each step of the research process? 
  • Give ample time for students to complete (and possibly repeat) all parts of the process?
  • Ask students to reflect upon the research process as well as the subject matter?
  • Evaluate and/or grade how the students understand and conduct the research process? 


The ideas and questions in this guide were construed and compiled from the following sources:

Assignment Ideas that Develop Information Literacy Skills by Pace University Library at http://www.pace.edu/library/pages/instruct/infoliteffectiveassignments.doc

Beyond Google: How Do Students Conduct Academic Research by Alison Head at www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue12_8/head/index.html

Designing Research Projects Students (and Teachers) Love by Doug Johnson at http://www.doug-johnson.com/

Notes to Instructors on Writing Good Research Assignments by Colorado State University Libraries at http://lib.colostate.edu/howto/instr2.html

Plagiarism-Proofing Assignments by Doug Johnson at http://www.doug-johnson.com/

Research Project Calculator provided by Minitex and MnLink at http://rpc.elm4you.org/


Created by Metronet, 2007

 

 

 

 

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.